(954) 444-2900

Mediation or Litigation? Choosing the Right Path in Contract Disputes

Mediation or Litigation? Choosing the Right Path in Contract Disputes

By: davidjohn June 5, 2023 1:43 am


When you are tangled in a contract dispute, you might feel like you are in the ring, gloves on, ready for a lengthy legal brawl. However, there is an alternative approach that’s often overlooked – contract mediation. So let us dive into this less combative path and see why it may be your ticket to a smoother resolution.

The Basics: Contract Mediation vs. Litigation

Contract Mediation Unraveled

Mediation is a voluntary process wherein a neutral third party, the mediator, helps the conflicting parties to reach a mutually beneficial agreement (Moore, 2014). It’s not about winning or losing but finding common ground where both parties feel satisfied.

Litigation Unleashed

On the other hand, litigation is a legal proceeding in court where a judge or jury determines the outcome. It is adversarial by nature, focusing on who is right or wrong based on the law (Federal Judicial Center, 2019).

Why Mediation Outweighs Litigation

Cost and Time Efficient

Mediation generally takes less time and costs less than litigation. According to the American Bar Association, mediation can be completed in a matter of hours or days, not weeks or months, like litigation.

Preserves Relationships

In business, relationships matter. Mediation encourages collaboration and understanding, thereby preserving relationships, unlike litigation, which can strain or sever relationships (Boulle, 2005).

Confidential and Flexible

Mediation proceedings are private and offer flexibility in solutions, while litigation is a public affair with rigid procedures (Macfarlane, 2017).

Benefits of Contract Mediation over Litigation

Benefits of Contract Mediation over Litigation

Emphasizing Control and Satisfaction

Mediation gives the parties control over the process and outcome, leading to a higher compliance rate since the solution is mutually agreed upon. Studies show that parties who mediate their conflicts are generally more satisfied with the process and outcome than those who go through litigation (Wissler, 2004).

Contract Mediation and Other Dispute Resolution Methods

Comparing to Arbitration and Negotiation

Arbitration is similar to litigation in that a third party makes a binding decision, while negotiation lacks a neutral third party. Mediation combines the best of both worlds – the neutrality of arbitration and the control of negotiation (Federal Judicial Center, 2019).

Case Study: Mediation Triumphs Over Litigation

Here is a real-world scenario showcasing the power of mediation. In 2018, two software companies clashed over contract issues. Initially, they chose litigation but soon realized its drawbacks – mounting legal fees, strained relations, and an uncertain timeline. They switched to mediation and resolved the dispute within weeks, preserving their business relationship and saving substantial time and money (World Intellectual Property Organization, 2019).

Authority Citations – Stating the Facts

Renowned legal scholars and organizations validate the benefits of mediation over litigation, including the American Bar Association, the Federal Judicial Center, and the World Intellectual Property Organization.

FAQs About Contract Mediation

Q1: Is mediation legally binding? Yes, once both parties agree on a resolution, it can be made into a legally binding agreement (American Bar Association).

Q2: Can I use a lawyer in mediation? 

Yes, you can choose to have a lawyer represent you during mediation, although it is not mandatory (Federal Judicial Center, 2019).

Q3: What if we cannot reach an agreement in mediation? 

If an agreement is not reached during mediation, parties can still pursue other legal remedies, including litigation (Moore, 2014).

Q4: How is the mediator selected? 

Both parties mutually agree on a mediator. This could be an individual or an organization specializing in mediation (American Bar Association).

Q5: How long does contract mediation usually take? 

The length of mediation can vary greatly depending on the complexity of the issues. However, it typically is much faster than litigation, often taking days or weeks instead of months or years (Boulle, 2005).

Q6: Is everything said in mediation confidential? 

Yes, mediation is a private process, and generally, anything said during mediation cannot be used in future litigation or arbitration (Macfarlane, 2017).

Conclusion: The Wise Path of Mediation

Conclusion: The Wise Path of Mediation

Choosing mediation over litigation for contract disputes is akin to choosing dialogue over duel. It is a smart, efficient, and respectful approach that leaves room for continued relationships and creative solutions. So, the next time you find yourself on the precipice of a contract dispute, remember to consider the path of mediation.

Experience Unmatched Legal Expertise with David L. John, Florida’s Professional Commercial Mediator

Navigating the legal landscape can be daunting and complex, so having the right expert by your side is crucial. Introducing David John, a highly skilled and versatile legal professional whose experience spans over 30 years as both a plaintiff and a defendant. 

With a unique blend of knowledge and practical business acumen, David John can help you resolve disputes in a swift, cost-effective, and dignified manner. Call David at 954) 444-2900 for a free online consultation today.


American Bar AssociationVisit Site
Federal Judicial CenterVisit Site
Moore, C. W. (2014). The Mediation Process: Practical Strategies for Resolving Conflict.View Book
Boulle, L. (2005). Mediation: Principles Process Practice.View Book
Macfarlane, J. (2017). The New Lawyer: How Settlement Is Transforming the Practice of Law.View Book
Wissler, R. L. (2004). The Effectiveness of Court-Connected Dispute Resolution in Civil Cases. Conflict Resolution Quarterly.View Article
World Intellectual Property OrganizationVisit Site